September 11 & Political Freedom

 
 

Photo Gallery:

Manila Launching

January 23, 2003

The September 11 and Political Freedom: Asian Perspectives focuses on political developments in the region following 9/11. In this new volume, arising from a conference of the Council of Asian Liberals and Democrats on globalisation, thinkers and observers of the region review the impact of 9/11 on the development of democracy and freedom in Asia. Collectively, these 11 essays reflect the 'after-shocks' being felt in the Asian region from the 9/11 attack.

 

Some extracts from the book:

 

To fight terrorism means not to allow it to be successful. The strange logic of terror is that if the US does retaliate by bombing some countries on its list, innocent lives will again be lost. In the eyes of many, it will be considered another incident of terror.

- Chaiwat Satha Anand

 

The root cause of violence may be found in the alienation, dualism, and antagonism generated by systemic marginalisation of vast segments of the world population... We must establish a more democratic and just global governance. We must pledge to a new rule of international law. No nation, large or small, should be exempted from the rule of international law. Unilateralism is not a legitimate answer to global problems.

- Majid Tehranian

 

Civil society in a number of Southeast Asian countries has been arguing for a paradigm shift in managing the affairs of the state and society, from an obsession with state security to a greater understanding of and focus on human society... The September 11 terrorist attack, which has unwittingly drawn in Southeast Asia, will complicate and frustrate the efforts towards that paradigm shift.

- Hadi Soesastro

 

Whether Asian governments choose to adopt a more multilateral approach... or whether, they continue to rely more  on Washington-centric bilateral engagement while the US descends into the depths of dark isolationism, in order to address the global problem of terrorism, will determine not only their success in fighting terrorism over the longer term, but also, how they are viewed by the rest of the international community.

- Lyal Sunga

 

What September 11 has demonstrated is that even while the information we have about another and ourselves has increased exponentially in recent years, our mutual comprehension of one another and ourselves may well have grossly deteriorated in quality.

- Subroto Roy

 

9/11 as reviewed by some of Asia's leading commentators.

 


CONTENTS

 

Notes on Contributors

 

Acknowledgements

 

Introduction

September 11 and Political Freedom: Asian Perspectives

by James Gomez and Alan Smith

 


 

CHaptER 1 : GLOBALISATION POST 9/11 CHALLENGES

                     FOR LIBERALS

                     by Kevin Hewison

 

CHaptER 2 : MITIGATING THE SUCCESS OF TERRORISM

                     WITH THE POLITICS OF TRUTH AND

                     JUSTICE

                     by Chaiwat Satha-Anand

 

CHaptER 3 : THE CENTER CANNOT HOLD: TERRORISM

                     AND GLOBAL CHANGE

                     by Majid Tehranian

 

CHaptER 4 : GLOBAL TERRORISM: IMPLICATIONS FOR

                     STATE AND HUMAN SECURITY

                     by Hadi Soesastro

 

CHaptER 5 : THE NEW TERRORISM: HOW SOUTHEAST

                     ASIA CAN COUNTER IT

                     by Andre Tan

 

CHaptER 6 : The us foreign policy of praetorian

                     unilateralism and the implications

                     for southeast asia

                     by Kumar Ramakrishna

 

CHaptER 7 : SOUTHEAST ASIA AND THE WAR AGAINST

                     TERRORISM: THE RISE OF ISLAMISM AND

                     THE CHALLENGE TO THE SURVEILLANCE

                     STATE

                     by David Martin Jones & Mike Lawrence Smith

 

CHaptER 8 : pROBLEM INHERENT AT SOURCE: THE

                     COMMUNICATION MEDIA IN POST 9/11

                     SOUTHEAST ASIA

                     by Jonathan Woodier

 

CHaptER 9 : 9/11 anti-terrorist measures and

                     their impact on human rights in asia

                     by Sinapan Samydorai

 

CHaptER 10 : US ANTI-TERRORISM POLICY AND ASIA'S

                              OPTIONS

                              by Lyal Sunga

 

CHaptER 11 : TOWARDS A GENERAL THEORY OF

                              GLOBALISATION AND TERRORISM

                              by Subroto Roy

 


 

September 11 sees civil liberties curtailed

in Asia: book

Agence France Presse
September 6, 2002
SINGAPORE

Related:
Singapore tightens security ahead of September 11

THE prospect of a rise of militant Islam "is of grave concern" in Asia, where governments are using US terrorism concerns to curtail civil liberties, according to a new book evaluating the impact of September 11.

"It may be too early to draw conclusions about the real impact of September 11 on Asia, but rather there is an awareness of a discernible chain of reactions or aftershocks," the editors say in their introduction.

September 11 and Political Freedom: Asian Perspectives is a collection of essays by academics on the "aftershocks" in the region since hijacked aircraft ploughed into US symbols of capitalist and military might a year ago.

Various chapters examine the inter-woven links between globalisation, poverty and terrorism, criticise the Association of Southeast Asian Nations' (ASEAN) shortcomings, and analyse Asian political reactions.

The book refers to increases "in rights abuses" such as discrimination, detention without trial, increased surveillance and invasion of privacy.

"The authors are articulating the rhetoric coming out of the region," said Southeast Asian political science researcher James Gomez, who co-edited the book with Uwe Johannen and Alan Smith of the Friedrich Naumann Foundation.

Critics of the poverty theory have pointed to the millionaire status of Osama bin Laden, seen as the mastermind and financier of the September 11 attacks.

"But where the rise of militant Islam is concerned, for this area poverty is a real issue," Gomez told AFP Friday ahead of the book launch in Singapore.

In the collection of 11 essays there is emphasis that Southeast Asia has been singled out as a region conducive for Islamic militant networks to resettle in the wake of the US-led war on terrorism.

"The 'under siege' atmosphere was used to justify several arrests and raids on so-called Islamic militants in the Philippines, Malaysia and Singapore.

"Indonesian authorities resisted for fear of the domestic political repercussions".

The prospect of a rise of militant Islam in Asia in the long term "is of grave concern for the region's security but its further development and likely impact can still only be guessed at," the editors say.

"More immediately, the essays... collectively suggest that the security-oriented responses of governments in the region may impede and slow the emergence of the free and dynamic civil society needed for a healthy democracy."

Sinapan Samydorai, president of the Think Centre in Singapore, in a chapter on human rights abuses, argues for an agreed definition of terrorism.

Without an agreement "it is likely that human rights abuses in the region will flourish," he said, noting an increase in discrimination, detention without trial, increased surveillance and invasion of privacy since September

Malaysia, Singapore, South Korea and Myanmar continued to detain people without trial, while the Philippines, Indonesia and Hong Kong have introduced or are drafting anti-terrorism laws with vague definitions of terrorism that open the possibility to criminalise peace campaign activities, Samydorai said.

ASEAN is accused of showing the same ineffectual response to September 11 as it did to the Asian financial crisis five years, in an essay by David Martin Jones, a senior lecturer at the University of Tasmania, and Michael Smith, a lecturer at the University of London.

In a chapter on surveillance in the region they say Asian intelligence services did not detect links between regional Islamic militant groups and al-Qaeda because it was not on the agenda of concern to the ASEAN leaders.

They conclude: "ASEAN is substantially a facade, reflecting a romantic vision of a handful of academics and peripatetic regional conference circuit speakers without either popular roots or strong state backing."

On globalisation, the editors say its failure to eliminate global inequalities "has helped unleash a vicious reaction."

They said the security-oriented, military-based response from the United States that has found favour with many governments in Asia risks "exacerbating the problems that are seen as causing terrorism."

 


Published and distributed in Singapore in 2003.                                          By Select Publishing Pte, Ltd.                                                                        In association with Friedrich Naumann Foundation

National Library Board (Singapore) Cataloguing in Publication Data September 11 & political freedom: Asian Perspectives / edited by Uwe Johannen, Alan Smith, James Gomez.

ISBN 981-4022-24-1

To order, please go to the select books website: www.selectbooks.com.sg

      PUBLICATIONS
     
      Tracking Aid
     
      Political Parties in Asia
     
    September 11
      & Political
      Freedom
     
      Democratic Transitions   in Asia
     
      The Political Dimensions of the Asian Crisis
     
   
    CALD NEWS
   
    ABOUT CALD
   
    CALD CONFERENCES & WORKSHOPS
   
    MISSIONS & VISITS
   
    RESOLUTIONS
   
    MEMBER PARTIES
   
    INTERNSHIPS
   
    CONTACT US
   
    PARTNERS
   
    GUEST BOOK
   
    SUBSCRIBE TO NEWSLETTER
   
     
     
     
     
     
     
    << HOME